September 4, 2019

Which ETFs Do I Choose?

With over 60 ETFs to choose from, selecting the correct ETFs that will reduce risks cut costs and still provide attractive returns can be a difficult, if not impossible task.

The Itransact Investment Platform solved this task seven years ago, by offering financial advisors a range of multi-managed risk adjusted ETF portfolios. Lance Solms, head of Itransact said that “We knew that the ETF market would become popular with advisors and investors creating the challenge of which ETFs to pick”.

Judging by their track record it seems Itransact has got it right!

Their recipe is quite simple explains Mr Solms

ETF selection

We first make sure that the ETFs selected are collective investment scheme, ensuring investors capital is protected against the unlikely event if insolvency from an ETF issuer. We then disqualify all ETFs that use so called smart beta, active or multifactor methods. These are not ETFs. They are mostly “dressed” up ETFs that attempt to “behave” like active managers or stock pickers and are best suited to be bought as single funds. We therefore only use unpolluted low cost “vanilla” ETFs as our building blocks. These ETFs provide us with broad, well-diversified exposure to a market. Each portfolio is designed to tolerate the failure of a stock or two within the ETF itself with little impact on the overall portfolio. Using plain vanilla ETFs also average out the price behavior signal we are looking for as their performance is the average of many stocks, tracking as specific asset class, making the ETF price return behavior more predictable. Dressed up ETFs are not as predictable add un-wanted risks and cost more.

Asset Allocation

We take the historical price and total return series (net of its Total Expense Ratio) of each and every ETF in the market and process that in a tried and tested propriety algorithm that tells us how ETFs behave in terms of producing a market view. From this process, we derive no more than 10 ETFs that are well diversified from one another and efficiently track  both domestic and offshore equity, real estate, bonds and money markets. We now need only select the lowest risk, highest return ETFs to represent each asset class according to the chosen risk bands that govern each portfolio range and allocate the capital by portfolio contents and risk weightings.

Portfolio Returns (Up to 31 July 2019)

Note that TERs of all portfolios are under 0.50% per annum including VAT making them very low cost.

DISCRETIONARY 1 YEAR 2 YEAR 3 YEAR 4 YEAR 5 YEAR  6 YEAR 7 YEAR
Conservative 6.97 6.73 5.77 5.74 5.91      –      –
Cautious 6.32 5.62 4.35 5.48 5.89 6.81 6.98
Moderate* 8.20 7.00 5.40 6.65 7.49 8.39 8.77
Growth 5.80 6.41 5.46 5.62 6.82 8.75 9.39
International 8.45 12.87 9.47 10.12 10.32 10.75      –
REGULATION 28 1 YEAR 2 YEAR 3 YEAR 4 YEAR 5 YEAR  6 YEAR 7 YEAR
Conservative 6.50 5.88 4.53 5.07 6.91 8.04      –
Cautious 6.16 3.99 3.54 4.80 6.13 6.14      –
Moderate 6.89 3.81 2.97 5.05 6.40 6.67      –
Growth 4.86 4.00 3.67 4.98 6.78 7.75      –

*Flagship product. Ter of 0.47%

Source: Index Solutions 2019